Guide: Ny Housing Stability & Tenant Protection Act

Human Verified 0

When Rosa’s landlord handed her a renewal offer with a 400 dollar monthly increase, she assumed she had two choices: pay it or move. She had lived in her Brooklyn apartment for six years, raised her daughter there, and could not afford a move on short notice. Then a neighbor told her about a 2019 New York law that changed the rules for rent increases, eviction, fees, and security deposits. Rosa learned that her increase required advance notice measured in months, not days, and that her landlord owed her a deposit accounting she had never received. The law did not make her housing cheap, but it gave her time, rights, and leverage she had not known she possessed.

The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, usually called HSTPA, rewrote New York’s tenant protections in a single sweeping law. It strengthened rent stabilization and rent control, capped application fees, limited security deposits, extended notice periods for rent increases and nonrenewals, and restricted how landlords can use a tenant’s history in court. The law applies statewide, with its strongest rent regulation effects in New York City and surrounding counties, but its fee, deposit, and notice rules reach tenants across the state. Any New York tenant or landlord who still operates by pre 2019 rules is operating on outdated law.

HSTPA matters most because it changed the balance of time. Before the law, a landlord could raise the rent or end a tenancy with relatively short notice, leaving tenants scrambling. After the law, notice periods stretch with the length of the tenancy and the size of the increase, giving tenants months to plan, negotiate, or find a new home. That extra time is the law’s most practical gift, and tenants who know the notice schedule can use it to avoid the panic that leads to bad decisions.

Rent Increases and Required Notice

HSTPA ties notice of a rent increase to two factors: how long the tenant has lived there and how large the increase is. A landlord who wants to raise the rent by less than five percent must give thirty days of written notice. An increase of five percent or more requires sixty days when the tenant has lived there for one to two years, and ninety days when the tenancy has lasted more than two years or when the increase reaches a higher threshold in some cases. Rosa’s 400 dollar increase on a 1,900 dollar rent was about twenty one percent, and her six year tenancy entitled her to ninety days of notice, not the thirty days her landlord had given.

The notice must be written and must state the new rent and the date it takes effect. A verbal warning about an increase does not start the clock, and a landlord who applies an increase without proper notice cannot collect it until proper notice is given. Tenants who receive a short notice increase should respond in writing, citing the required period, and keep a copy of the response. A landlord who corrects the notice gains nothing by arguing, since the corrected notice simply restarts the clock the law already required.

Rent regulated tenants gain additional protection. For rent stabilized apartments, annual increases are set by the Rent Guidelines Board, not by the landlord’s preference, and the landlord must offer a renewal lease with a choice of a one or two year term. HSTPA repealed vacancy decontrol, which had let landlords deregulate apartments when they became vacant or reached a rent threshold, and it limited the rent increases landlords could claim for building improvements. A rent stabilized tenant facing an increase above the guideline should check the registration status of the apartment with the state housing agency before paying.

Fees, Deposits, and Application Costs

HSTPA capped the fees landlords can charge tenants, and the caps change the economics of renting in New York. Application fees are limited to 20 dollars, a sharp drop from the hundreds of dollars some landlords previously charged. A landlord who charges 150 dollars for an application is violating the law, and a tenant who pays it can demand a refund. The cap applies to most residential rentals statewide, and it removes one of the quiet costs that made apartment hunting expensive.

Security deposits are limited to one month’s rent for most units, and landlords must return the deposit within fourteen days of move out, with an itemized statement of any deductions. A landlord who misses the fourteen day deadline loses the right to keep any part of the deposit, a penalty that gives the deadline real force. Tenants should photograph the unit at move in and move out, and should provide a forwarding address in writing, since the deposit clock runs cleanly only when the landlord knows where to send the accounting.

The law also restricts other charges. Landlords cannot charge a fee for a background or credit check beyond the application fee cap, cannot require a tenant to pay for a broker the landlord hired, and cannot charge excessive late fees without lease support. A tenant who is asked for a fee that seems high should ask the landlord to identify the legal basis in writing, since many fees that were routine before 2019 are now unlawful. Keep receipts for every fee paid, because a refund claim needs proof of payment.

A Numbered Example: Rosa’s Increase and Deposit

Rosa paid 1,900 dollars a month for six years when her landlord proposed 2,300 dollars, an increase of 400 dollars or about twenty one percent. Her landlord gave thirty days of notice. Under HSTPA, her six year tenancy and the size of the increase required ninety days of notice, so the landlord’s notice was sixty days short. Rosa wrote back citing the ninety day rule, and the landlord issued a corrected notice giving her the full ninety days. The correction did not stop the increase, but it gave Rosa two extra months to negotiate, save, or search, which was worth far more than the argument.

Rosa also discovered a deposit issue. She had paid a 1,900 dollar deposit when she moved in, and her landlord had never provided an itemized accounting for a 300 dollar deduction claimed at her previous renewal. Under HSTPA, the landlord owed an accounting within fourteen days of move out, and any deduction without a timely accounting was vulnerable. Rosa’s written inquiry produced a 300 dollar refund, since the landlord could not produce the accounting. Between the extra sixty days of notice and the 300 dollar deposit refund, Rosa gained about 1,100 dollars of value from knowing the law: sixty days at the old rent saved her roughly 800 dollars against the increase, and the deposit refund added 300 dollars, while the time to plan saved her a rushed move that would have cost far more.

The example shows why the law’s details matter in dollars. A tenant who accepts a short notice increase loses the planning time the law grants, and a tenant who never asks for a deposit accounting loses money the law would have returned. Rosa’s gains came from two letters, not from a lawsuit, which is how HSTPA most often helps: it gives tenants rules to cite in ordinary correspondence.

Eviction Protections Under HSTPA

HSTPA strengthened eviction protections in several ways. Landlords seeking eviction for nonpayment must now give a fourteen day rent demand before filing, replacing the older three day demand, which gives tenants nearly two extra weeks to pay or seek help. Landlords must also give longer notice before ending a tenancy, with the period tied to the length of the tenancy. A tenant who has lived in a unit for more than two years is entitled to ninety days of notice of nonrenewal in many cases, a dramatic change from the short notices of the past.

The law also limits the use of a tenant’s court history. Landlords cannot refuse to rent to an applicant solely because the applicant appeared in a housing court case, a practice that had blacklisted tenants who had won their cases or settled them. This change matters most for tenants who fought a landlord once and then faced rejection after rejection, since a court appearance no longer follows a tenant like a conviction. Landlords who screen applicants must look at the substance of a case, not the mere fact that one existed.

Holdover cases, where a landlord seeks to remove a tenant after the lease ends, also changed. Landlords must now give proper notice tied to tenancy length, and tenants gain more time to find new housing before a court orders removal. The law did not end evictions, and a tenant who stops paying rent without a defense will still face removal, but it slowed the process and gave tenants realistic time to respond. Time, again, is the protection that matters most.

State Rules Beyond New York

HSTPA is a New York law, but its ideas have spread. Several states and cities have since adopted longer notice periods, application fee caps, and deposit deadlines modeled on New York’s approach. A tenant moving from New York to another state should never assume the same protections travel, since most states still allow shorter notices and higher fees. A landlord operating in New York and another state must keep separate procedures for each, because a notice that satisfies New York will usually satisfy a shorter notice state, but a notice written for a short notice state will fail in New York.

Tenants in New York City gain an extra layer through the city’s housing agencies and rent administration. Rent stabilized tenants can file complaints with the state Division of Housing and Community Renewal over improper increases, missing services, or harassment, and the agency can order rent reductions or refunds. Tenants in nonregulated units rely more on the courts and on the attorney general’s tenant protection unit. Knowing which agency fits the problem saves weeks of misdirected complaints.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

A New York tenant who does not know HSTPA pays for the ignorance in concrete amounts. Accepting a short notice increase can cost 800 dollars or more in lost planning time, paying an unlawful application fee costs 130 dollars or more per application, and missing a deposit deadline claim can cost the full deposit amount. A landlord who ignores HSTPA faces steeper costs, since unlawful fees must be refunded, improper notices restart the clock, and illegal lockouts or retaliation can produce damages. The law rewards the side that knows it, and it punishes the side that guesses.

Bottom Line

The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act gives New York tenants time, caps, and deadlines that did not exist before 2019.

Know the notice period for your tenancy length, refuse fees above the cap, demand a deposit accounting within fourteen days, and answer any eviction notice with the longer timeline the law provides. The law works best when tenants cite it in writing, early, and calmly. For the general tenancy rights that apply everywhere, see tenant rights and responsibilities under a lease agreement, and for eviction notice rules, read how to respond to an eviction notice and eviction notice types and tenant rights.

Adam Bothun
Founder & Editor-in-Chief

Adam Bothun is a lawyer specializing in sample letters and document sharing. He runs Lease Agreement Hub, offering legal templates and resources to simplify contracts and agreements for individuals and businesses.