A group of three friends bought a house together, each contributing a different amount toward the down payment, and moved in without a written agreement. When one friend wanted to sell her share two years later, the others disagreed about the price, about who could buy the share, and about whether the house should be sold at all. The disagreement became a lawsuit that cost 24,000 dollars in legal fees and forced a court ordered sale of the whole house, when a written tenants in common agreement would have settled every question for the price of an attorney’s drafting fee. Tenants in common agreements are the documents that keep shared ownership from becoming shared litigation.
Tenants in common, often abbreviated TIC, is a form of co ownership in which two or more people each own an undivided interest in a property, with each owner’s share stated as a percentage. Each owner can use the whole property, each owner can sell, gift, or will their share independently, and each owner’s share passes to their heirs rather than to the other owners. Tenants in common differs from joint tenancy, where owners hold equal shares with a right of survivorship, meaning a deceased owner’s share passes automatically to the surviving owners. Tenants in common suits owners who contribute unequally, who want independent control of their shares, or who want their shares to pass to their own heirs.
A tenants in common agreement, also called a TIC agreement, is the written contract among the co owners that governs their relationship. The agreement states each owner’s share, each owner’s financial contributions, how expenses are divided, how decisions are made, how an owner can exit, and what happens on death, divorce, or disagreement. Without an agreement, state law supplies default rules that may not match the owners’ intentions, and disputes are resolved by courts rather than by the owners’ own terms. With an agreement, the owners’ intentions govern, and disputes are resolved by the document the owners signed when relations were good.
What the Agreement Should Cover
A TIC agreement should start with ownership shares and contributions. Each owner’s percentage should be stated clearly, with the down payment, closing costs, and any unequal contributions recorded. A friend who contributed 60,000 dollars toward a 100,000 dollar down payment holds a different share from one who contributed 20,000 dollars, and the agreement should reflect that difference rather than assuming equal shares. The agreement should also state how future contributions, such as a roof replacement or a major renovation, are funded, whether by proportionate shares, by equal shares, or by a separate agreement for each project.
The agreement should state how ongoing expenses are divided, including mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, utilities, and maintenance. Most TIC agreements divide expenses by ownership share, so a 50 percent owner pays half the mortgage and taxes, while a 25 percent owner pays a quarter. The agreement should also state what happens when an owner fails to pay, including late fees, interest, and the other owners’ right to cover the shortfall and claim reimbursement. An owner who covers another’s shortfall should gain a lien or a claim against the defaulting owner’s share, so the covering owner is not left subsidizing the defaulter indefinitely.
Decision making is the section owners most often neglect and most often regret neglecting. The agreement should state which decisions require unanimous consent, such as selling the property or taking on new debt, and which require only a majority, such as routine repairs or choosing a contractor. The agreement should state how votes are weighted, whether by ownership share or by one vote per owner, since the two methods produce different outcomes when shares are unequal. A decision rule agreed in advance prevents the deadlock that forces a court to decide, since a court ordered partition sale is the default remedy when co owners cannot agree.
Exit, Death, and Disagreement
Exit provisions are the most valuable part of a TIC agreement, since every co ownership eventually faces an owner who wants out. The agreement should state how an owner can sell their share, whether the other owners hold a right of first refusal to buy the share before it is offered to an outsider, and how the share price is determined. Common price methods include an appraisal by a mutually agreed appraiser, an average of two appraisals, or a formula based on the property’s value minus the mortgage balance, multiplied by the owner’s share. The agreement should state the time frame for the other owners to exercise a right of first refusal, usually thirty to sixty days, and what happens if they decline.
Death and incapacity provisions protect both the deceased owner’s heirs and the surviving owners. The agreement should state that a deceased owner’s share passes to their heirs or estate, since tenants in common has no survivorship right, and should state whether the heirs step into the deceased owner’s rights and duties under the agreement. The agreement should also state whether the surviving owners can buy the deceased owner’s share, and at what price, since heirs who inherit a share may want cash rather than co ownership with strangers. A buyout provision for death, like one for voluntary exit, converts a potential dispute into a transaction with a price and a deadline.
Disagreement provisions complete the agreement. The agreement should require mediation before litigation, state the mediation procedure and cost sharing, and state whether arbitration or court litigation follows if mediation fails. The agreement should also address partition, the legal process by which a co owner can force a sale or division of the property, and should state whether the owners waive or limit partition rights in favor of the buyout procedure. A partition waiver, where enforceable, keeps the property intact while an owner exits through buyout, rather than forcing a sale of the whole property because one owner wants out.
A Numbered Example: Three Friends and a House
Three friends bought a house for 300,000 dollars, with a mortgage of 240,000 dollars and a down payment of 60,000 dollars. Ana contributed 30,000 dollars, Ben contributed 20,000 dollars, and Carla contributed 10,000 dollars, giving them shares of 50 percent, 33 percent, and 17 percent respectively. Without an agreement, the friends assumed equal shares and equal expenses, and Ana, who had paid half the down payment, subsidized Ben and Carla by 10,000 dollars and 3,333 dollars respectively over the first two years of equal expense sharing. When Carla wanted to sell her share, the friends disagreed about whether her share was 17 percent or 33 percent, and about the price.
With a TIC agreement stating the shares and the price method, Carla’s exit would have been a transaction, not a lawsuit. The house had appreciated to 360,000 dollars, with a mortgage balance of 220,000 dollars, giving equity of 140,000 dollars. Carla’s 17 percent share of equity came to 23,800 dollars, calculated as 140,000 dollars times 17 percent. Ana and Ben, holding a right of first refusal, could have bought Carla’s share for 23,800 dollars, split by their shares, or declined and allowed Carla to sell to an outsider at the same price. The transaction would have cost an appraisal fee of 500 dollars and attorney fees of 1,500 dollars, or 2,000 dollars total.
Without the agreement, the friends spent 24,000 dollars in legal fees disputing the shares, the price, and the right to sell, and the court ordered a partition sale of the whole house for 350,000 dollars, after costs of 15,000 dollars, leaving 115,000 dollars of net proceeds after the 220,000 dollar mortgage was paid. The friends divided the proceeds by the court’s determination of equal shares, or about 38,333 dollars each, which overpaid Carla by 14,533 dollars relative to her 23,800 dollar true share, and underpaid Ana by 19,167 dollars relative to her 57,500 dollar share of the net proceeds. The lawsuit cost 24,000 dollars in fees plus 15,000 dollars in sale costs, and produced a division that matched nobody’s contributions. The agreement would have cost 2,000 dollars and produced the correct division.
State Rules Change Co-ownership
Tenants in common rules vary by state, and co owners should check the local law before signing. Some states presume tenants in common when a deed does not state the form of ownership, while others presume joint tenancy for married couples. Some states limit partition waivers, treating a waiver as unenforceable after a certain period, while others enforce them fully. Some states impose specific requirements for TIC agreements in condominium conversions or multi unit buildings, where TIC ownership is used as an alternative to condominium ownership. A TIC agreement drafted without regard to state law may contain provisions a court will not enforce, which is why an attorney licensed in the property’s state should review the agreement.
Co owners should also address use and occupancy rules in the TIC agreement, since shared ownership without use rules produces friction over guests, pets, and exclusive spaces. The agreement should state whether each owner has exclusive use of a bedroom or unit, how common areas are shared, whether guests can stay long term, and whether pets are allowed. A TIC agreement for a multi unit building should assign each owner a specific unit for exclusive use, with common areas shared by all, while a TIC agreement for a single house should assign bedrooms and state the rules for shared kitchens and bathrooms. Use rules agreed when relations are good prevent the daily friction that turns co ownership sour.
Co owners should also plan for financing changes, since a TIC property’s mortgage, refinancing, or home equity borrowing affects every owner. The agreement should state whether refinancing requires unanimous consent, how a new loan is divided among owners, and what happens if one owner wants to borrow against their share alone. A lender who lends against a single TIC share, where permitted, gains a lien on that share only, while a lender who refinances the whole property requires every owner’s signature. The financing clause prevents one owner from encumbering the property without the others’ knowledge, which is the kind of surprise that ends co ownerships.
The Cost of Doing Nothing
Co owners without a TIC agreement pay in legal fees and forced sales, often 24,000 dollars or more for a single dispute, plus sale costs and a division that matches nobody’s contributions, as the three friends’ case shows. Co owners with a TIC agreement pay an appraisal fee and attorney fees of about 2,000 dollars when an owner exits, and gain a division that matches their contributions. The agreement costs a drafting fee when relations are good, and saves a lawsuit when relations sour. No group should buy property together without one.
Bottom Line
Tenants in common lets co owners hold unequal shares, sell independently, and pass shares to heirs, but only a written TIC agreement makes that flexibility safe.
State the shares, the contributions, the expense division, the decision rules, the exit and buyout procedure, and the death and disagreement provisions, and have an attorney in the property’s state review the document. A group that buys together without an agreement buys a lawsuit along with the house, while a group that signs one buys a clear path out for any owner who needs it. For the lease rules that apply when co owners rent out a shared property, see tenant rights and responsibilities under a lease agreement and notice to vacate rules.
